I vaguely remember writing this some time ago. I think I meant to send it for inclusion in an anthology, but for one reason or another, this never happened. I think it’s a little disturbing and jarring, as it was meant to be. I’d be interested in reading comments (the illustration is AI, generated from the WordPress site).
The young lady who was now seated before me, facing me across the desk in my study, seemed strangely self-possessed. She sat bolt upright in her chair, hands clasped over her brocade reticule, looking me in the eye as she prepared to speak.
“Mr Harrison,I understand that you are the country’s leading expert on matters that may be described as ‘psychic’.”
Flattering indeed, but modesty, coupled with a sense of honesty that has never entirely deserted me, caused me to reply in the following terms. “Miss” (I had remarked the absence of a wedding ring almost as soon as she had entered) “Greenfell, while it is true that I may be numbered amongst those who have devoted their energies to explorations of the uncanny, which some may indeed choose to dub ‘psychic’, I would not lay claim to the position which you have just ascribed to me. Why, either Sir Oliver Lobbs, or Professor Crooker of Cambridge University, or both, have far greater claims to that title.”
“Stuff and nonsense!” was my fair young visitor’s response. “Both of them are far too credulous of the fakes and imposters to be found in the field.”
Since this corresponded with my views on the two individuals in question, I held my peace while nodding, I trusted in a grave and serious fashion, to indicate my agreement with this opinion.
There was a pause of a few seconds, during which a half-smile crept over Miss Greenfell’s face. A face which had, I confess, acquired a certain amount of charm for me in the past minute or so.
“It was you, was it not, who laid to rest the Norbury ‘ghost’? A matter of some muslin and bamboo poles manipulated from the first-floor window by means of a fishing rod?”
I silently acknowledged my part in this matter. It had made me no friends in the popular penny press, whose coverage of the “ghost” had undoubtedly boosted the number of subscribers to their publications.
“And was it not you who discovered the mechanical hammer responsible for the strange knocking sounds to be heard at Madame Likoffsky’s séances, thereby exposing her as a fraud, and leading to her arrest?”
Again, I agreed wordlessly that this was so. The affair of Madame Likoffsky was, in my opinion, a small masterpiece of observation and subsequent deduction. It had to be acknowledged, though, that it had given me little pleasure to see Madame consigned to the dock. She had always struck me as a pleasant and amiable soul, being less grasping and greedy than many of her ilk, though she had been unable to resist taking the large fees paid to her by the Marchioness of Saltburn. It was those fees which had led her son, fearful that his inheritance was to vanish into the maw of Madame Likoffsky, to engage me with a view to taking action against her.
There was another lull in the conversation, during which I had the distinct impression that my general character and probity were being put under the microscope.
“Tell me, Mr Harrison,” she said at length. “Are you a believer in these phenomena? By which I mean, of course, not whether you believe in their occurrence, because of course they occur all too frequently. I ask rather, whether they have a cause that may be as yet unexplained by science.”
I was rather taken by the phrase “as yet” in that last speech of hers. It argued a belief and faith in science to provide the answers to questions, and at the same time, to acknowledge the limitations of our knowledge to date.
“An excellent question,” I answered. “I confess that I have not as yet encountered a phenomenon that could not be explained simply and without reference to the supernatural, even in cases where I have been unable to identify the cause. May I ask whether you are yourself a believer in such causes?”
“That, Mr Harrison, is a difficult question to answer. May I presume on approximately another thirty minutes of your time?”
I was expecting no other callers that afternoon. “Very well. I take it this will be a long story? May I take notes?”
“No notes will be required. I believe you will know the story I am about to relate to you. May I adjust the light in this room?” Without waiting for permission, she stood, crossed to the window, and half-closed the blind. “Now,” reseating herself, “give me your hands,” she requested, holding out her own to me.
This little minx has the audacity to conduct what appears as though it will be a séance with Harold Harrison, in his own study? Well, let her try then.
“I will not expect you to close your eyes,” she laughed, “given that you would almost certainly covertly open them in order to detect my cheating. However, please remain as still as possible.”
With that she closed her own eyes, and within a minute or so she had started to breathe in a pattern that I recognised as one often adopted by so-called mediums.
“Your older brother, Edward, died five years ago in the war in South Africa,” she informed me. “He died of yellow fever.” There seemed to be no attempt to disguise her voice or to assume that she was speaking as a spirit, as other mediums do.
I started a little at this. Though this was perfectly true, and the news of his death in the war was public knowledge, there was no public record of the cause of his death.
“True?” she asked me.
“True,” I acknowledged.
“Your father,” and this was said with a sense of embarrassment, “conducted an affair behind your mother’s back with a woman named Olive Blanchett. You discovered this when you were fourteen years old as the result of reading a letter left in the pocket of your father’s coat which you had borrowed one day. You never mentioned this to anyone, including your father, but kept this knowledge to yourself. It shattered your faith in your father, and you never again regarded him in the same light as you had done previously.”
To say I was shaken was an understatement. Every detail of this was exactly as she had described, including the fact that I had kept this knowledge to myself all these years.
“True?”
Reluctantly, I agreed. “True,” I said.
Another silence. I confess I was sweating. How much did this woman know about me, and how had she come by her knowledge? At length she spoke.
“Your breakfast this morning consisted of porridge, followed by devilled kidneys, and an egg. You sent the first egg back to the kitchen as it had been boiled for too long, and you requested your man Mathews to inform Cook that she could not expect to remain much longer in your employment if she was unable to even boil eggs satisfactorily.”
Though far less of an emotional memory than the previous revelation regarding my father, again, this was an exact account of my having broken my fast that very morning.
“True?”
“True,” I told her.
She opened her eyes. “Now, Mr Harrison, you will tell me how I know these things about you, if you please.” She sat back in her chair, a faint smile playing about her lips. She appeared to be completely unaffected by the trance, if such it was, that had so recently affected her.
“My brother,” I began. “His death was published in the Gazette. There is no secret there. As to the manner of his death, it is conceivable that you are friends or at least are acquainted with some of his former comrades in arms, possibly even the doctor who attended him in his last illness.”
“Very good,” she answered me. I felt like a schoolboy being patronisingly complimented by a schoolmistress.
“Breakfast,” I mused. “You could have talked with Cook or with Mathews before meeting me.”
“Indeed I could have done,” she agreed.
“But the business regarding my father worries me,” I said. “I cannot imagine how you might know this, unless you had been present at the time when I read the letter.”
“I was not,” she assured me.
I spread my hands in a gesture of defeat.
“Then perhaps you have presented me with that rara avis, an event for which no explanation is forthcoming, though there are perfectly adequate explanations for the other two.”
“Indeed they are perfectly adequate,” she said. “But they happen not to be the case,” she added simply.
“Then how..?”
“I am as much in the dark as you,” she confessed. “Let me tell you a little more. For the past few years, I have made it my business, as you have made it yours, to rid the world of these fraudulent mediums who take the money from the credulous. Unlike you,” and here she smiled faintly, “I do not seek publicity for my work, nor do I refer the perpetrators to the authorities, but make it clear that unless they cease their operations, they will suffer for it, without, however, being explicit as to the nature of the suffering. Somehow, this has always been effective.”
In the course of my work, for the past few years, I had noticed that some of those mediums I had been pursuing had suddenly ceased operating without any reason being ascribable. Now, I told myself, the reason was sitting, seemingly very much at ease, and regarding me with a quizzical smile.
“I am sure you have rendered a great service to society through your actions,” I said. “But I am still in the dark as to how..?”
“I was about to come to that point,” she said. “I was talking to one of these mediums – you would never have stooped to concern yourself with Mary Rosenheim, I am sure – she was practicing her craft in a cellar in Shoreditch and her clientele are not of the kind with which I would imagine you associating – but as I was speaking to her, I found myself uttering words about her – and I have no idea from where they came. I was describing children she had borne out of wedlock some twenty years earlier, who were living in Germany. Not only did I know of their existence, I knew their names and the names of their fathers.” She paused. “Poor Mary was convinced I was a witch about to curse her, and abandoned the profession of medium immediately.”
“You really have no idea how you came to know these things?”
“None, I assure you.”
“And has it happened again?”
“Oh yes, several times. And not always with these mediums.”
“And you find yourself telling people about things which by rights you should not know? Just as you did now with me.”
“Always. These range from the trivial, like what you ate for breakfast, through to things like Madame Rosenheim’s children, or your father’s indiscretion.”
“How extraordinary.” And so it was. I had never heard of such a thing. Mental telepathy would explain a sort of reading of the mind, but you would have to assume that the person whose mind was being read would actually be thinking of the event being described. I had completely forgotten about the incident with the egg, and as for the business with my father… I had buried that in a corner of my mind, and though never completely forgotten, I had not consciously remembered it for many years.
“It’s a great gift,” I told her. “It could be used for good, in police-courts and so on to determine guilt or innocence.”
She shook her head. “I fear not. It is unpredictable. It is not everyone whose secret thoughts are open to me. Indeed, it is a very small portion of the population whose minds are open to me in this way.”
“Have you found anything that these people have in common?” I asked her.
“I have.” She appeared to be nervous, biting her lower lip and fidgeting in her chair. “But I have no wish to tell you. It is – shall I say? disturbing.”
“I am not easily disturbed,” I told her. “You may safely tell me.”
“Very well then. Prepare yourself. It is this. Every person whose mind has been opened to me has died within a week of my telling them their thoughts.”
I sat stunned. “Would this include me?”
“I have no reason to believe otherwise.”
“How many?”
“Including you, fifty-three.”
“How did the others die? I mean, did they kill themselves out of shame at your revelations?”
She shook her head. “Not as far as I can tell. Accidents, sudden illness, two were murdered.”
“And I am to be the fifty-third? I fear that your pattern of coincidences will end with me.”
“Oh, I think not.” She rose, and made for the door. “Tell me, Mr Harrison, what is your picture of the personification of Death?”
“A traditional one, I suppose. A hooded skeletal figure, brandishing a scythe.”
She smiled – not the faint smile she had worn earlier, but a death’s-head grin. “Sometimes that has been so, Mr Harrison, but I much prefer this shape since I adopted this body a few years ago.” She opened the door and stepped through it. “Goodbye, Mr Harrison. We shall not meet again.”
Let me know what you think of this, please.






